Choosing the right mailing list is one of the most important steps in building a successful direct mail campaign. Even the best-designed postcards or brochures won’t bring results if they aren’t reaching the right audience. Whether you’re a nonprofit looking to increase donations or a small business trying to attract new customers, the list you choose determines how effective your mailing will be.

Why the Mailing List Matters
Your mailing list is the foundation of your campaign. It defines who will see your message, how many people will receive it, and what kind of results you can expect. A carefully targeted list ensures your materials are landing in the hands of people who are most likely to respond. On the other hand, a poorly chosen list leads to wasted printing and postage costs.
Types of Mailing Lists
There are several types of mailing lists to consider, and each one has its own strengths:
- House Lists
These are lists you build internally, often made up of past donors, customers, or people who have expressed interest in your organization. House lists usually perform the best since they reach people who already have a connection with you. - Response Lists
These lists are made up of people who have responded to similar offers in the past. For nonprofits, that could mean people who have donated to similar causes. For small businesses, it could include buyers of products in your industry. - Compiled Lists
These lists are created from public records, surveys, and other data sources. They can be segmented by demographics, geography, or lifestyle factors. While not as strong as house or response lists, compiled lists are often the most affordable and can help you reach new audiences.
Key Factors to Consider
When selecting a mailing list, think about these important factors:
- Audience Fit: Does the list match the demographics, interests, and needs of your ideal customer or donor?
- Geography: For local businesses and nonprofits, targeting by zip code or neighborhood helps you focus on people nearby.
- List Quality: Ask how often the list is updated. An outdated list with bad addresses can drive up your costs.
- Quantity vs. Quality: A smaller, well-targeted list will usually perform better than sending thousands of pieces to an unfocused group.
Using EDDM as an Option
Every Door Direct Mail (EDDM) is another way to target households without needing a purchased list. With EDDM, your mailers go to every address in a chosen postal route. This option is great for local restaurants, retail shops, and community-based nonprofits that want to saturate a specific area.
Partnering with a Printing Company
Working with a printing company that also offers mailing services makes the process smoother. At Inkwell Printing Company, we help nonprofits and small businesses not only design and print their materials, but also choose the right mailing list for them. This ensures your campaign is both cost-effective and results-driven.
Final Thoughts
Your message is only as strong as the list you send it to. By taking the time to choose the right mailing list, you can stretch your marketing dollars further and see better results. Whether you rely on a house list, purchase a targeted list, or use EDDM, the key is making sure your mail reaches the people who matter most.
Contact us with any of your printing needs!
For more helpful information check out our blog at: /advice-from-the-printer/
And for more information on Inkwell Printing Company check out our website at: www.inkwellstl.com








